Perfect Choice

Replaceable Pillow Top Mattress

Why should you be stuck with one type of padding?

The Perfect Choice mattress has a replaceable topper that lets you change your material and firmness based on season, age, person, health, situation, or sheer whim.

Do you love to fall into a sea of softness? Try the Perfect Choice Gel with its extremely plush 2-inch layer of gel-infused Memory Foam topping a 1-inch layer of polyurethane foam. 

Do you enjoy the support and airiness of latex? The Perfect Choice Latex topper comes with 3 inches of natural Talalay latex.

Why should you be stuck with one type of padding?

The Perfect Choice has a replaceable topper that allows you to change your material and firmness based on season, age, person, situation, or sheer whim.

Do you love to fall into a sea of softness? Try the Perfect Choice Gel with its extremely plush 2-inch layer of gel-infused Memory Foam topping a 1-inch layer of polyurethane foam. 

Do you enjoy the support and airiness of latex? The Perfect Choice Latex topper comes with 3 inches of natural Talalay latex.

Options for All

COMPARE OUR PERFECT CHOICE MATTRESSES

Perfect Choice Gel Logo

Extremely plush gel-infused memory foam

Overview

PRICE: $$$

HEIGHT: 13 IN.

FEATURES: DOUBLE-SIDED W/ TOPPER

Firmness Range

perfect choice gel firmness range

*1=Most Plush 8=Most Firm

Materials

MATTRESS TOP

  • 1.25 in. Quilted Cover
  • 2 in. Gel-Infused Memory Foam
  • 1 in. Polyurethane Foam

MATTRESS CORE

  • 1 in. Polyurethane Foam
  • Resinated Pad
  • Polyester Pad
  • Protective Mesh
  • Mid-Section Support Pad
  • 12.5 Gauge Steel Innerspring & Double Edge Slide Supports
  • Mid-Section Support Pad
  • Protective Mesh
  • Polyester Pad
  • Resinated Pad 
  • 1 in. Polyurethane Foam

Options

SKU #

#PC-MF-

Name

Extra Plush

Firmness

1

Sizes

All options available in six standard sizes:

Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, and California King.

Custom sizes available by special order. Reference size and SKU# when ordering.

Foundations

Perfect Choice comes standard with a 14 slat foundation.

  • 14 slat wood foundation
  • Low-profile 14 slat wood foundation
  • 81-coil boxspring
  • Low-profile boxspring
Perfect Choice Latex Logo

Supportive and luxurious natural Talalay latex, available in three firmnesses

Overview

PRICE: $$$$

HEIGHT: 13 IN.

FEATURES: DOUBLE-SIDED W/ TOPPER

Firmness Range

perfect choice latex firmness range

*1=Most Plush 8=Most Firm

Materials

MATTRESS TOP

  • 1.25 in. Quilted Cover
  • 3 in. Natural Talalay Latex

MATTRESS CORE

  • 1 in. Polyurethane Foam
  • Resinated Pad
  • Polyester Pad
  • Protective Mesh
  • Mid-Section Support Pad
  • 12.5 Gauge Steel Innerspring & Double Edge Slide Supports
  • Mid-Section Support Pad
  • Protective Mesh
  • Polyester Pad
  • Resinated Pad 
  • 1 in. Polyurethane Foam

Options

SKU #

#PC-55-

#PC-75-

#PC-95-

Name

Extra Plush

Plush

Firm

Firmness

2

4

6

Sizes

All options available in six standard sizes:

Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, and California King.

Custom sizes available by special order. Reference size and SKU# when ordering.

Foundations

Perfect Choice comes standard with a 14 slat foundation.

  • 14 slat wood foundation
  • Low-profile 14 slat wood foundation
  • 81-coil boxspring
  • Low-profile boxspring
Perfect Choice Gel Logo

Extremely plush gel-infused memory foam

PRICE: $$$

HEIGHT: 13 IN.

DOUBLE-SIDED W/ TOPPER

Perfect Choice Latex Logo

Supportive and luxurious natural Talalay latex, available in three firmnesses

PRICE: $$$$

HEIGHT: 13 IN.

DOUBLE-SIDED W/ TOPPER

Perfect Choice Gel Logo

Extremely plush gel-infused memory foam

perfect choice gel firmness range
Perfect Choice Latex Logo

Supportive and luxurious natural Talalay latex, available in three firmnesses

perfect choice latex firmness range

*1=Most Plush 8=Most Firm

Perfect Choice Gel Logo

Extremely plush gel-infused memory foam

Mattress Top

  • 1.25 in. Quilted Cover
  • 2 in. Gel-Infused Memory Foam
  • 1 in. Polyurethane Foam

Mattress Core

  • 1 in. Polyurethane Foam
  • Resinated Pad
  • Polyester Pad
  • Protective Mesh
  • Mid-Section Support Pad
  • 12.5 Gauge Steel Innerspring & Double Edge Slide Supports
  • Mid-Section Support Pad
  • Protective Mesh
  • Polyester Pad
  • Resinated Pad 
  • 1 in. Polyurethane Foam
Perfect Choice Latex Logo

Supportive and luxurious natural Talalay latex, available in three firmnesses

Mattress Top

  • 1.25 in. Quilted Cover
  • 3 in. Natural Talalay Latex

Mattress Core

  • 1 in. Polyurethane Foam
  • Resinated Pad
  • Polyester Pad
  • Protective Mesh
  • Mid-Section Support Pad
  • 12.5 Gauge Steel Innerspring & Double Edge Slide Supports
  • Mid-Section Support Pad
  • Protective Mesh
  • Polyester Pad
  • Resinated Pad 
  • 1 in. Polyurethane Foam
Perfect Choice Gel Logo

Extremely plush gel-infused memory foam

SKU #

#PC-MF-

Name

Extra Plush

Firmness

1

Perfect Choice Latex Logo

Supportive and luxurious natural Talalay latex, available in three firmnesses

SKU #

#PC-55-

#PC-75-

#PC-95-

Name

Extra Plush

Plush

Firm

Firmness

2

4

6

Perfect Choice Gel Logo

Extremely plush gel-infused memory foam

Perfect Choice Latex Logo

Supportive and luxurious natural Talalay latex, available in three firmnesses

All options available in six standard sizes:

Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, and California King.

Custom sizes available by special order. Reference size and SKU# when ordering.

Perfect Choice Gel Logo

Extremely plush gel-infused memory foam

Perfect Choice Latex Logo

Supportive and luxurious natural Talalay latex, available in three firmnesses

Perfect Choice comes standard with a 14 slat foundation.

  • 14 slat wood foundation
  • Low-profile 14 slat wood foundation
  • 81-coil boxspring
  • Low-profile boxspring
Quiet Night Luxe Logo
Swirl design

Dream Customer Reviews

Swirl design

Perfect Choice Warranty

Don’t lose sleep over a poorly designed mattress, or one that doesn’t stand up over time. At Monarch Rest, we back all of our mattresses with industry-leading warranties that let you rest easy.
Read More

Perfect Choice FAQs

Does the Perfect Choice Warranty apply to the mattress topper as well as the mattress?

Yes, the same warranty applies. For the first 10 years, we will replace or repair for free any mattress topper with workmanship defects or component failures, including impressions exceeding 1/2 inch. You pay nothing but transportation. For the next 10 years, we will replace or repair for 50% off any mattress with workmanship defects or component failures. Impressions must exceed 1 inch. Read the full warranty for details.

Can I buy another topper separately from the mattress?

Yes, that is one of the benefits of the Perfect Choice. Say the topper on your replaceable pillow top mattress gets soiled or you’re ready for a different firmness, you can swap it out, no problem.

Is the Perfect Choice mattress a hybrid mattress?

Yes, the Perfect Choice is a replaceable pillow top mattress that would fall into the hybrid mattress category. A hybrid mattress is an innerspring mattress that has specialty foam padding (latex or memory foam or a combination).

Do hybrid mattresses use memory foam or latex?

Hybrid mattresses can use either, or sometimes a combination of both, in their comfort layer. Memory foam hybrids offer closer body contouring and a slower, more cushioned feel, while latex hybrids respond more quickly, sleep cooler, and tend to last longer. The Perfect Choice collection offers both options, so you can choose whichever fits your sleep preferences and budget.

What's inside a hybrid mattress?

A hybrid mattress typically has three main components: a coil support core (usually encased coils), a transition layer of firmer foam or latex to smooth the transition between coils and comfort layers, and a top comfort layer of memory foam, latex, or polyfoam for cushioning. Different manufacturers use different materials and thicknesses on their hybrid options. Perfect Choice is a hybrid mattress with an added (and replaceable) pillow top.

Is a hybrid mattress better than memory foam?

Hybrid mattresses are known to sleep cooler, with more bounce and edge support than all-foam mattresses, because of the coil base, which allows airflow beneath the comfort layers. Memory foam works well for close body contouring and motion isolation. Sleepers who want the pressure relief of foam without the "stuck" feeling might prefer the hybrid combo.

How thick is a typical hybrid mattress?

Most hybrid mattresses range from 10 to 14 inches thick, with the coil base typically making up 6-8 inches and the comfort/transition layers making up the remaining 4-6 inches. Thicker hybrids usually mean more cushioning in the comfort layer, though the coil base height also plays a large role in overall support and durability. Monarch Rest’s Perfect Choice uses both heavy-gauge coils and thick layers of padding–along with a gel or latex topper–for ultimate comfort.

What is gel memory foam, and does it actually sleep cooler?

Gel memory foam is foam infused with gel in beads, swirls, or layers and designed to mitigate heat more effectively than traditional memory foam.

How is latex foam different from memory foam?

Latex foam is made from natural or synthetic rubber and responds instantly to pressure with a bouncier feel. In contrast, memory foam is a polyurethane-based material that conforms closely to the body and responds more slowly. Latex also tends to be more durable and naturally resists dust mites and mold, and it is usually a more costly option. At Monarch Rest, we’ve chosen natural Talalay latex for its strength, comfort, and antimicrobial properties.

What's the difference between a hybrid and a "mattress with pillow top"?

A pillow top is another layer of cushioning (foam, fiber, or down) sewn onto the top of a mattress, which can be added to either an innerspring or a hybrid mattress to increase softness. When people refer to a mattress as a hybrid, they’re specifically talking about the underlying construction: a coil base paired with substantial foam or latex comfort layers built into the mattress itself, not just added on top. Perfect Choice has both the comfort layers and a replaceable pillow top.

Do hybrid mattresses need to be rotated?

Yes, rotating a hybrid mattress 180 degrees every 3 to 6 months helps evenly distribute wear across both the coil base and the comfort layer, extending its lifespan. Most hybrids are one-sided and shouldn't be flipped, since the comfort layer is only on one side. Perfect Choice is the exception. It can be flipped, but of course, the pillow top should always be placed on the sleeping side!

Trusted by These Organizations and Thousands of Happy Sleepers

We get it. Your sleep is too important to risk. Check out these trusted certifications.

CertiPUR-US Certified Foam®

CertiPUR-US Certified Foam®

American Crafted

American Crafted

BBB Accredited Business

BBB Accredited Business